# Vegan Chocolate for Plant-Based Confections Topic radar · 180 documents · 2021-01-01–2026-11-14 · updated 2026-11-20 Canonical: https://slate.greyb.com/radar/vegan-chocolate-for-plant-based-confections/innovations ## In one minute ### Two substitutes have been built, and they remove different things from the bar Chocolate can now be made without dairy by replacing the milk solids with a plant fraction, or without cocoa by rebuilding a chocolate-like mass out of other crops. The first route keeps the cocoa and swaps the dairy note. The second keeps the process and swaps the bean. Both run on refining, conching and tempering as they already exist. The chickpea route is described as mixing the fraction into molten chocolate ingredients and then refining, conching and tempering in the usual way [1], and the cocoa-free route ferments, roasts and conches its raw materials with the same equipment used for cocoa beans [2]. Neither needed a new unit operation, which is why the filings sit on ingredients rather than on machinery. 1. [BE1029592B1](/?paper=BE1029592B1&utm_source=radar&utm_medium=dashboard) 2. [yumda.com](https://www.yumda.com/en/news/1187626/tuev-sued-provides-information-on-cocoa-free-chocolate-alternatives.html) ### Only two companies in the record sell the invention they filed on Puratos sells its plant-based milk and white couvertures under Belcolade, made with rice syrup and chickpea protein with no dairy or nut content, which is the fraction its own patent family claims at 40% protein or more on a dry basis. Hershey is the other. It moved its 2021 Oat Made trial into permanent lines in 2023, Reese's Plant Based cups in March and an Extra Creamy bar with almonds and sea salt in April, made with oats, after filing on roasted grain flour as the milk-solids replacement and extending the idea to heat-treated legume flour. ### Most of the filings come from the companies that sell the ingredient Puratos holds the chickpea dairy-replacer family, published across at least fifteen jurisdictions with members in Belgium, Chile, India, Russia, Vietnam and Australia, all claiming a protein fraction of 40% or more on a dry basis. Cargill's answer is plant protein plus a plasticiser above 30% cocoa solids, published as a family spanning Canada, Brazil, China and Japan. Fuji Oil claims a roasted legume powder for reduced-cocoa chocolate and an oil composition that removes oily mouthfeel, and Mitsubishi Chemical claims a dairy-free emulsion for water-containing chocolate. ### The dairy note comes from a treated flour or a purified protein The filings split into two families by how far the plant material is processed. Hershey stays close to flour: cereal flour dry-heated until its colour, flavour and moisture change, used in place of nonfat milk solids, extended in a later filing to heat-treated legume flour. Its retail bar follows the same idea, drawing its milkiness from oat and rice flours rather than from an isolated protein. ### The bars on sale run on oat, almond and rice, and their sellers did not patent any of them Lindt's vegan range is gluten-free oat milk powder and almond paste, sold as HELLO in Germany and the UK and as Classic Recipe elsewhere, and the company still describes the line as made with oat milk. Its only filing in this record covers enzymatically hydrolysed buckwheat flour, an ingredient that does not appear in those bars. ### Filing follows the markets where the claim can be made Indian publications are the largest single group among the patents behind this analysis, at four, ahead of China and the United States at two each and Chile at two. The same offices recur across families: Puratos in India, Vietnam, Russia and Chile, Cargill in China and Japan, Nestlé in Chile and Cargill in Brazil. ### Purity of the fraction decides whether the bar tastes of pulse or of milk The patent record treats a crude flour and a purified fraction as different products in the mouth. Lower-purity chickpea flour and other legume proteins are described as producing green, pulse-like off-notes and a flat flavour with no dairy association. A fraction at about 95% protein with under 1% fat is described as giving creamy, nutty notes close to milk chocolate. ### The alternative-chocolate ingredient that has reached another company's branded product is cocoa-free The clearest case of a novel base crossing into someone else's product is ChoViva, Planet A Foods' sunflower-based chocolate, which coats Candy Kittens' Treets line sold at £2.20 per 120g. The dairy-replacer half of the field shows nothing comparable in the sales record: chickpea, legume flour and buckwheat are sold as couvertures and ingredients rather than appearing on a third party's label at retail. ## Overview The hard problem in vegan chocolate has moved off the recipe. The dairy note is now a documented ingredient specification, held by the same suppliers who sell cocoa and processing capacity, so a chocolate brand's realistic choice is to buy a couverture rather than invent one. The money and the litigation have followed that shift: capacity and brands change hands, and the largest company in the category now spends part of its effort in court. ## Research ### The cocoa-free route keeps the cocoa process and changes the substrate Cocoa-free chocolate is made by fermenting, roasting, conching and refining other crops the way cocoa is treated, with sunflower seeds and oats ground into an aromatic concentrate and then mixed with sugar and vegetable fats. The substrates differ by company: sunflower and oat at Planet A Foods, carob, pumpkin seed and chickpea at Foreverland, upcycled grape seed at Cargill and Voyage Foods, and fermented broad bean, chickpea or lentil in a filing from Nuokeke. ### Losing the milk takes structure out of the chocolate, and the recipes add it back Milk solids do mechanical work in a bar, and their absence shows up in measurements. A vegan sample without milk had roughly half the yield stress of the dairy version, along with lower viscosity, lower hardness and lower adhesiveness. Yield stress governs how a molten mass holds its shape and how it coats, so something in the recipe has to take over that job. ### The harder invention is the filling, where plant proteins have to do the work of fat Mars claims a layered bar of 1 to 65% plant-based nougat, 25 to 65% plant-based caramel and 15 to 55% plant-based chocolate, with the nougat made by whipping aquafaba and plant protein with sugar syrup into an aerated frappe. The claim is about how a filled bar holds together and chews, which is the part of a known format that plant proteins copy worst. ### Graininess has a measured threshold, and it sets how coarse a plant base can be Solid particles below a certain size cannot be felt in chocolate. A trained panel put the detection threshold above 40 micrometres, judging 60 micrometre chocolate significantly grittier than 40. That matters here because a flour or protein fraction arrives with its own particle-size distribution in a system where the sugar and cocoa particles were already tuned against each other. ### Independent tasting of the new fractions is the thinnest part of the evidence What exists is the patent's own sensory description and the supplier's own launch material. The peer-reviewed work on dairy-free chocolate uses almond milk and soy protein, oat milk and millet milk as the substitute, which leaves the legume and chickpea routes tested mainly by the companies selling them. ## Market ### Retailers' own brands are the fastest-growing part of the shelf and carry no invention at all Tesco put a Finest Free From range into the Christmas aisle: Belgian chocolate and Seville orange segments, cocoa-dusted truffles and sea-salt buttons, each at £3.25 for 90g. Aldi's Moser Roth Vegan Blonde sat in the same supermarket comparison as Cadbury's bar and the own-brand free-from lines of M&S and Sainsbury's. ### Independent brands reach the shelf on formats and nostalgia, at a price a couverture can carry The Undairy Co built a Celebrations-style selection box of Creme Eggs, honeycomb, chocolate orange and hazelnut pralines recreated in dairy-free chocolate. NOMO brought a Bounty-style bar back with a toasted coconut filling and a new recipe, and added Salted Popcorn and Birthday Cake into Sainsbury's. Catherine's Originals put a miniature O'Bar inside a 15-piece gifting box, on a bar range retailing from £9.20 for 200g. ### The textures the patents protect have no product on the record Nestlé's filings describe micro-aerated chocolate stabilised with non-cocoa vegetable oil and a water-based filling thickened with hydrocolloids to hold a creamy mouthfeel. Mars filed on a layered bar of plant-based nougat, caramel and chocolate built on an aquafaba frappe, while what Mars has on the shelf in this record is Galaxy vegan bars and oat-based chocolate milkshakes. Cargill's claim combines plant protein with a plasticiser to restore snap. ### The suppliers are now selling processing behaviour to manufacturers Plamil's November launch is a bake-stable dairy-free milky chocolate for food manufacturers, sold on holding shape and appearance through heat treatment and made in its dedicated free-from plant, ahead of the FiE trade fair. That is the market position the ingredient side has settled into: the differentiated product is not a bar but a specification for someone else's line, and the claim is about how it behaves in an oven rather than how it tastes on its own. ## Strategy ### The money goes into feedstocks and into capacity the processors own Most of the 2026 commitments went to cocoa-free ingredients. Foreverland raised €6M in March, taking its total to €9.4M, against a Puglia plant rated above 500 tonnes a year. Döhler bought Nukoko in June and pushed it through its existing production and account network. Endless Food Co takes €1M a year from Loacker's venture arm. Cargill launched NextCoa with Voyage Foods, and Mondelēz became the first major food company to use cell-cultured chocolate, from Celleste Bio. ### The brand layer changes hands instead of growing LoveRaw's assets went to Smart Organic after administration, with the buyer's manufacturing capacity named as the prize. Hands Off and Chocolatemakers merged to run three brands off one solar-powered factory, targeting €20M of revenue by 2030. Mondelēz took a majority stake in Undercover Snacks, paying for 25,000 retail doors and a quinoa-crisping process and keeping the founders in place. ### The largest company spends part of its effort in court Within days of agreeing the Undercover deal, Mondelēz filed at the High Court against Catherine's Originals over the shape of the O'Bar and wrote to Moo Free about the word "snowball". Both matters sit at the letter and writ stage, with no defence or judgment on record. ### What is left at the product end is a format and a listing Hershey turned a test bar into a permanent line in 2023. The 2026 additions come from much smaller firms: Well&Truly's oat m&lk Easter truffles into Sainsbury's nationwide, and Moon Magic's six-flavour line sold direct and through Amazon. ### The published science has not followed the industry The peer-reviewed work nearest this problem is about other routes. Published studies cover a chickpea and carob spread that replaces cocoa and sugar, and milk chocolate in which whey, buckwheat, oat flour and pea isolate replace part of the sugar, with the plastic viscosity of the mass rising from 4.4 to 10 Pa·s depending on the ingredient. Neither tests the chickpea protein fraction that Puratos and its customers sell. ## Areas - Ingredient Innovation · 99 documents - Market Expansion · 23 documents - Consumer Engagement · 21 documents - Brand Competition · 18 documents - Product Development · 12 documents - Manufacturing · 5 documents